For many immigrants arriving in the United States, the concept of birthright citizenship is both empowering and confusing. This legal principle ensures that most children born on US soil automatically become citizens, regardless of their parent’s immigration status. However, misinformation and political debates often cloud the facts.
What is birthright citizenship?
Birthright citizenship is the legal guarantee that anyone born in the United States is a US citizen. This practice is rooted in the Citizenship Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, which was ratified in 1868 to overturn the Dred Scott v. Sandford decision that denied citizenship to African Americans. The amendment states: “All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.”
Key Exceptions:
- Children born to foreign diplomats (due to diplomatic immunity).
- Children born in territories under US military occupation.
Protecting your US-born child’s legal rights
As an immigrant parent in the United States, ensuring that your US-born child’s citizenship is recognized and properly documented is crucial. Birthright citizenship grants your child significant legal protections and opportunities, but these rights must be supported by proper documentation.
Here are the steps you can take to safeguard your child’s citizenship and navigate any challenges that may arise:
- Obtain a US birth certificate
The first and most important document for proving your child’s citizenship is their US birth certificate. This document is issued by the state where your child was born and serves as the primary proof of their citizenship. After your child is born, the hospital will typically assist you in completing the necessary paperwork to register the birth with the state’s vital records office. If you give birth outside a hospital, you will need to contact your local vital records office directly to file a birth certificate application.
A birth certificate is essential for accessing services such as education, healthcare, and government benefits. It also serves as a foundation for obtaining other key documents like a Social Security number and passport.
- Apply for a US passport
A US passport is another critical document establishing your child’s citizenship and providing international travel privileges. You can apply for your child’s passport as soon as their birth certificate is issued.
To apply, you will need:
- Your child’s original or certified birth certificate.
- Proof of parental relationship (usually the birth certificate suffices).
- Identification for both parents (e.g., passports or driver’s licenses).
- A completed DS-11 application form.
If one or both parents are undocumented and lack identification, it is still possible to apply for a US passport for their child, but certain considerations and steps must be taken:
- Providing Parental Information on Form DS-11: The application form (DS-11) requires information about the parents, including names, dates of birth, and places of birth. However, it does not specifically ask for immigration status. Parents can provide accurate information without disclosing their undocumented status. For example, they can list their place of birth and indicate they are not US citizens without fear of triggering immigration enforcement, as the passport application process is managed by the State Department, not immigration authorities.
- Identification Requirements: Both parents must present valid photo identification when applying for the child’s passport. If the parents do not have traditional forms of ID such as a driver’s license or passport, alternative forms of identification may be accepted depending on the circumstances. Parents should consult the State Department’s guidance or visit a passport acceptance facility to explore acceptable alternatives.
Once you have gathered the necessary documents and addressed any challenges related to identification, the next step is to submit the application at a designated passport acceptance facility, such as a post office or courthouse. Completing this process not only secures your child’s ability to travel internationally but also provides an additional layer of proof of their US citizenship that can be invaluable in various legal or administrative situations.
- Keep all documents safe
Once you have obtained your child’s birth certificate and passport, it is essential to store these documents securely. Consider keeping them in a fireproof safe or safety deposit box and making copies for backup purposes.
- Be prepared for challenges
While birthright citizenship is protected under the Fourteenth Amendment, there may be instances where your child’s citizenship is questioned—particularly in situations involving immigration enforcement or legal disputes.
Common scenarios:
- If one or both parents are undocumented or on temporary visas, immigration authorities may scrutinize your family’s status.
- Errors in documentation (e.g., misspelled names on birth certificates) can lead to complications when applying for other benefits or identification documents.
If you encounter any challenges, consult an experienced immigration attorney immediately. They can help resolve issues related to documentation errors, legal disputes, or questions about your child’s citizenship status.
- Understand your child’s rights
As a US citizen, your child has access to numerous rights and opportunities:
- Education: Your child can attend public schools and qualify for financial aid when pursuing higher education.
- Healthcare: They may be eligible for Medicaid, CHIP (Children’s Health Insurance Program), or other government-supported healthcare programs.
- Legal Protections: As a citizen, your child has full constitutional protections under US law.
It is important to educate yourself about these rights so you can advocate effectively for your child.
Myths vs. facts about birthright citizenship
Myth 1: Birthright citizenship can be ended by a president’s executive order.
Fact: For over 150 years, the courts upheld this principle, including a landmark Supreme Court decision in United States v. Wong Kim Ark (1898). In this case, the Court ruled that children born in the US, even to noncitizen parents, are entitled to citizenship under the Fourteenth Amendment unless their parents fall under specific exceptions (e.g., foreign diplomats or enemy soldiers during wartime).
Attempts to change or limit birthright citizenship through executive orders have been consistently blocked by courts as unconstitutional. For example:
In 2025, President Donald Trump issued an executive order seeking to deny citizenship to children born in the US to undocumented immigrants or those on temporary visas. Federal judges quickly blocked this order, citing its conflict with the Fourteenth Amendment and long-standing legal precedents.
Changing birthright citizenship would require amending the Constitution with a two-thirds majority vote in both houses of Congress or a constitutional convention called by two-thirds of state legislatures. The proposed amendment must be ratified by three-fourths (38 out of 50) of state legislatures or state conventions. This process ensures that constitutional amendments reflect broad national consensus, making it highly unlikely for birthright citizenship to be altered.
Myth 2: Parents can gain citizenship through their US-born child.
Fact: The claim that parents can gain citizenship through their US-born child is a common myth. The reality is far more complex and does not provide a “shortcut” to legal status. A US-born child cannot sponsor their parents for legal residency until they turn 21. This means there is no immediate benefit for undocumented parents when their child is born in the US.
Even when the child reaches 21, the parents must meet stringent requirements to be eligible for a green card. For example, they must have no significant criminal record or other factors that could make them inadmissible under US immigration law. If the parents entered the country illegally, they may face additional barriers, such as being required to leave the US and apply for a waiver to return legally. This process can take years and is not guaranteed. Immigration enforcement can still detain and deport parents, even if they have children who are US citizens.
Myth 3: Birthright citizenship encourages illegal immigration.
Fact: Studies show immigration decisions are driven by safety, jobs, and family—not citizenship for future children. Ending birthright citizenship would increase the undocumented population by leaving children stateless. For example, if children born to undocumented parents were denied citizenship, the unauthorized population in the US could grow from 11 million to 24 million by 2050.
Without birthright citizenship, children born in the US might not automatically gain citizenship in their parents’ home countries either, leaving them stateless. Stateless individuals lack access to fundamental rights such as education, healthcare, and legal protections, which could lead to increased poverty and vulnerability over generations.
Myth 4: Only wealthy ‘birth tourists’ benefit from this rule.
Fact: The myth that only wealthy “birth tourists” benefit from birthright citizenship is misleading, as the vast majority of children born to noncitizens in the US are part of mixed-status families who are building long-term lives in the country.
“Birth tourism” refers to the practice of traveling to another country, such as the US, specifically to give birth so that the child can acquire citizenship of that country. While this practice does occur, it is relatively rare. Estimates suggest that around 33,000 births annually in the US may be attributed to birth tourists, representing a tiny fraction of the approximately 3.7 million total births in the US each year. Most birth tourists plan their trips well in advance, pay for their medical expenses out of pocket, and return to their home countries shortly after giving birth.
To address concerns about birth tourism, US visa policies have already been tightened. Since 2020, pregnant women applying for visitor visas (B-2 visas) must prove they are not traveling primarily to give birth and demonstrate they can pay for any medical expenses incurred during their stay.
Recent challenges to birthright citizenship
In January 2025, former President Donald Trump signed an executive order aimed at denying US citizenship to children born in the United States to undocumented immigrants and individuals on temporary visas. This action marked one of the most direct challenges to the principle of birthright citizenship in modern history. However, federal courts quickly blocked the order, which deemed it “blatantly unconstitutional.” Legal experts and immigrant advocates argue that the order directly violates the Fourteenth Amendment of the US Constitution.
While the executive order is currently blocked, lawsuits are ongoing as immigrant rights organizations and legal experts challenge its legality. Opponents of birthright citizenship argue that the Fourteenth Amendment’s framers did not intend for it to apply to children of undocumented immigrants or temporary visa holders. However, this interpretation has been widely rejected by courts.
As of now, birthright citizenship remains fully intact. Children born in the US continue to receive automatic citizenship under the Fourteenth Amendment. However, this legal challenge underscores ongoing political debates about immigration and citizenship policies.
What this means for you:
- If you are an immigrant in the US, it’s important to know that your child’s citizenship is protected by constitutional law.
- In rare cases where your child’s citizenship is questioned (e.g., during interactions with immigration authorities), consult an experienced immigration attorney immediately.
- Stay informed about legal developments regarding birthright citizenship, as future political efforts may seek to challenge this long-standing principle.
How Stump and Associates can help
Birthright citizenship is a cornerstone of American equality, ensuring every child born here has a fair chance to thrive. While political debates may cause uncertainty, the Constitution and courts have consistently protected this right. For newcomers, understanding these rules empowers you to plan for your family’s future with confidence.
If you have questions about your child’s status or need legal support, contact Stump and Associates for personalized guidance rooted in decades of immigration experience.
Looking for Immigration Help?
Stump & Associates is Oklahoma City’s most respected immigration law firm. With more than 30 years of experience, we know how to handle cases just like yours.
Comments are closed